Eddie Cottle argues that the new UDF will only strengthen the ANC government.

Ceruti argues the new UDF signifies a crack within the Alliance and for the necessity for the social movements to get involved in it to build mass struggle.

Oupa Lehulere argues that, instead of orientating to Cosatu, the task for militants is to orientate towards the struggles that are emerging outside of it as the best way to build the working class movement.

Prishani Naidoo argues the new UDF is yet another attempt to hold back struggle against the neo-liberal policies of the ANC government and questions the centrality of the industrial working class in that struggle.

Harvey argues that a united front with Cosatu is the best way for the social movements to grow.

Heinrich Bohmke argues Desai does not call for an orientation to Cosatu. Instead, Desai is calling for Cosatu to change its orientation to the social movements.

Oupa Lehulere replies to the critiques, arguing that his main argument, against an orientation to Cosatu, has not been understood, with orientation being confused for organisational tactics.

statement to the meeting of CosAtU and other organizations of 22 August 2005 by communities.